Skip to Content

What Do Scallops Taste Like? [Definitive Guide]

Scallops are classified as shellfish. They have external covering is a two-part shell covering a soft-bodied membrane.

The soft-bodied invertebrate is the edible part of the scallop, which is its adductor muscle. Scallops roe is also considered a delicacy in some parts of the world.

This article will cover what capers taste like and common questions related to its taste.

What Do Scallops Taste Like?

Scallops taste is mild. Most people consider scallops unique.

Well-cooked scallops have a slightly sweet, delicate, and buttery taste. The seashells have an intriguing mix of rich and light flavours. They are also soft and succulent.

Expect your scallops to have a briny saltwater essence. Yet, they shouldn’t have a fishy taste.

Scallops’ texture is firmer than the more common crabs or lobsters. Some people even describe what scallops taste like mild white fish with a hint of crab.

If you have never eaten scallops, it might be tough to tell whether you will like it or not. If you don’t eat most of the popular seafood, it’s normal that you wonder whether you might like them.

But if you eat crab legs, shrimps and lobsters, you most likely can eat scallops.

With scallops, the less fishy they are, the safer. You can be sure that fishy scallops are most likely unsafe.

If your scallops smelly very fishy, they are likely to be already stale or spoiled.

Fresh and health scallops shouldn’t have a smell. Asides a faint smell like the ocean, your scallops should be odourless.

Scallops are also considered really sweet. They are popularly known as the candy of the sea.

Interestingly enough, the sweet taste isn’t offensive. It is unique and aromatic.

Furthermore, scallops are fleshy and soft in texture. People compare them to marshmallows.

While their texture can be described as somewhat slimy, it is mostly just chewy. They are like a seafood marshmallow.

Depending on the type of scallops, you can either have them taste salty or sweet. Bay scallops are salty while sea scallops are sweet.

Even people that don’t naturally enjoy seafood eat scallops. Because of the rich taste, it is a best seller.

The unique seafood flavour with a mild sweetness stands out the scallop from other types of water animals.

On a general note, chefs prefer to cook scallops. This is because they are already tasty. They don’t require a lot of effort to make them into a delicious meal.

Although some season scallops heavily, it is not necessary. They work well both with and without a lot of additional spices and flavours.

Cook scallops while fresh to get the best natural flavours.

Do Scallops Taste Like Shrimp?

Shrimps and scallops are similar. They are both rich in flavour and texture.

Shrimps have the sweet seafood flavour that can also be found in scallops. They also have a soft or neutral texture like the latter.

However, scallops are softer and chewier than shrimps.

My Scallops Taste Like Ammonia?

Scallops should not smell or taste like ammonia.

Fresh scallops don’t have any prevailing aroma. They typically have a faint sweet smell or an oceanic smell.

Their taste is light and briny, not heavy or metallic.

If your scallops taste or smell like ammonia, do not eat them. The smell of ammonia in scallops shows that they are bad.

Whether raw or cooked, as long as it has the smell, it is not edible. Do not eat them, no matter how faint the ammonic smell is.

What to Eat with Scallops

There are several ways to prepare your scallops.

Add butter to bring out the creamy richness which is already present in this seafood. Butter enriches many seafood dishes.

Use fresh lemon juice to season your scallops. This gives it an acidic jolt that emphasises its unique flavour.

Add lemon juice in small bits so that you won’t overwhelm the scallops’ flavour.

Scallops also go well with minimal amounts of garlic. With garlic, the seafood dish gains an earthy taste.

Another scallop flavour enhancer is white wine. Use white wine to bring out scallop’s rich juiciness.

You can eat scallops with meats as well. The surf and turf dish combines seafood and meat in one meal. It tastes particularly delicious when made with scallops.

Lastly, try combining bacon and scallops. The delicate and creamy scallops flavour complements bacon’s salty smokiness perfectly.

Can You Eat Raw Scallops?

Yes, you can eat raw scallops.

Raw scallops are a delicacy. But you must note a few things before you eat them.

Find ones that aren’t inhabited by helminths, and this pretty much completes the task.

Also, be sure not to eat them alone. Raw bivalve adductor muscles might be tasty, but they need little support.

Try eating fresh scallops with something acidic. Try using lemon juice, olive oil and a pinch of salt.

Also, serve the scallops cold. They taste good cold.

Try not to drown out the taste of scallop by too much dressing. If you do, you will miss the feeling you took the risk for.

Can Pregnant Women Eat Scallops?

Yes, you can. Eating scallops can continue even while you are pregnant.

While you can eat scallops, you have to take extra care while preparing it.

The extra attention just helps to make them safe for pregnant people.

Here are some things to consider eating scallops whilst pregnant:

  • Make sure your seafood is fresh, the fresher, the better.
  • Once your scallops smell like ammonia, they are gone off.
  • Only use scallops that are pearly white. Any yellowing one with a fishy smell is bad for you.
  • They must be firm and dry, in or out of the shell. Anyone wet, soft or mushy is bad.
  • Some scallops are water-packed to keep them pumped. While it might not be bad, they are of low quality.
  • Only use scallops that are dry or dry-packed on the label.

Defrost frozen scallops overnight in the refrigerator. This keeps them from spoiling. Defrosting under running or water or at room temperature either keeps them frozen or spoils them quicker.

After defrosting in the refrigerator, let the scallops return to room temperature before cooking. Simply let them sit out of the fridge for 15 minutes.

How to Cook Scallops

Scallops’ cooking time depends on how big they are. Bigger means longer. Jumbo scallops or sea scallops should be cooked for an extended period. Bay scallops are smaller, so they require lesser cooking time.

The recommended cooking temperature for scallops is 145f/63c. Use 450f/232c for your pan-searing and on the second flip, the scallops’ centre should reach 130f / 55c.

Scallops continue to cook after you remove them from the heat source. If removed at 130f, they should finish at the recommended mark.

Can You Eat Scallops Medium Rare?

Yes, you can. If you can eat scallops raw, you can eat them medium-rare.

If you choose to eat raw seafood, eat only those that have been previously frozen.

The temperature should kill any parasites.

However, if you are pregnant or have a weakened immune system, only eat scallops that are cooked to the recommended state.

Are Scallops Healthy?

Yes, scallops can be healthy.

Like any other seafood, scallops are rich in protein. They are a low-fat protein source.

They are also rich in many vitamins and minerals.

Scallops have omega 3 fatty acids, zinc, selenium and B12.

Noteworthy is the amount of sodium present in scallops. This is also true of many shellfish.

How Do You Know When Scallops Are Done?

If you are cooking your scallops, different methods have different preparation times.

You can prepare your scallops by sautéing, deep-frying, grilling, poaching, pan-searing, broiling, poaching, stir-frying, or baking.

Whichever way you are cooking your scallops, wait till they fully cooked inside.

Scallops are the safest when fully cooked. To fully cook scallops, let them reach an internal temperature of 145° F.

Scallop Substitutes

Use lobster for a sweet flavor in stews and dishes.

Abalone is also a great scallop substitute. They are very sweet to the taste. However, they tend to be expensive. This makes them a poor substitute choice.

Does your meal require another sweet white fish? Try fresh shark steaks instead of scallops.

To Sum Up

Eat your scallops as you please — raw, medium rare, or cooked.

You can choose to fry, grill, broil, pan-sear or smoke your scallops.

You can also use them as substitutes in dishes with similar shellfish or seafood.

Whichever, you try to do, know this — scallops always turn out tasty when cooked right. They make a delicious meal!