Best Honey Mustard Brands 2021

Mustard is a popular condiment that is made by grinding or mixing the seeds of the mustard plant and combining them with a range of other ingredients to create one of many types of mustard.

Whether you love to pour your honey mustard dressing on chicken, salads, roasted veggies or potatoes, you probably want to make sure you get the best product for your budget. 

This article will review the best honey mustard brands on the market and other factors to consider when buying honey mustard.

Disclaimer: Medmunch is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.

Top Honey Mustard Brand Comparison

Best Honey Must Brand Reviews

Trader Joe’s Honey Pale Ale Mustard

Check Price on Amazon

Deliciously Rich Gourmet Honey Mustard With The Added Depth Of Pale Ale 

If you’re looking for more of an Artisan honey mustard, the kind you would get on a hot dog at a food festival, then this Trader Joe’s honey pale ale mustard could be perfect for you.

It’s got all the spice and sweetness of honey mustard, but with an extra kick to boost the flavor of your meal. 

This product is unique in the use of craft pale ale to add an extra flavor dimension to the condiment. Whilst there is a warming mustard base and a floral honey tone, you get an earthy, grainy, autumnal taste from the pale ale that’s simply delicious.

Use as it is, or to make salad dressings and marinades.

Why we like it:

  • High-quality ingredients
  • Unique addition of craft pale ale
  • Simple, recognisable ingredients
  • Versatile

What we don’t like:

  • Quite sweet overall, which may not suit some cuisines 

Stonewall Kitchens Honey Mustard Aioli

Check Price on Amazon

Farmers Market Style Honey Mustard Perfect With Fries & Chicken 

Stonewall Kitchens started out as a farmers market stall business, selling delicious jams, jellies and other gourmet treats to hungry customers.

With that kind of history, you just know that any condiment made by Stonewall Kitchens is going to be packed full of flavor. 

The standout feature of this exciting product is that it is an aioli, which is a French type of mayonnaise.

It has still got all the sweet, aromatic fragrance of honey, and the warming spice of mustard, but the way it is combined with the creaminess of aioli is what takes it to the next level.

It’s also extremely versatile and can be perfect for perking up sandwiches, as a chicken marinade, or as a delectable dip for crab cakes. 

What we like:

  • Versatile
  • A great alternative to standard mayo
  • Not too hot
  • Creamy, delicious texture

What we don’t like:

  • May not be ‘mustardy’ enough for some 
  • Could be considered a higher budget product

Boars Head Honey Mustard

Check Price on Amazon

All Natural Honey Mustard With A Hint Of Horseradish Heat

Lovers of natural condiments and healthier products will love this Boars Head honey mustard. It’s made with no caramel coloring, no MSG and is totally gluten-free.

Instead, the deliciously warming flavor comes from a combination of recognisable spices, sugars and ingredients to delight the palate of any honey mustard fan. 

If you’re looking for a hot twist on honey mustard, you’ll love that the deli-style product uses earthy, warming horseradish for an extra kick. At its base, it is a classic honey mustard using freshly ground select mustard seeds and rich golden honey. 

It can be used for marinades, sauces and dips, but especially stands out in thick meaty sandwiches. 

What we like:

  • Double heat base with horseradish and mustard
  • Versatile 
  • No nasties
  • Perfect for use in meaty sandwiches

What we don’t like:

  • Could be too spicy for some customers 
  • Quite sweet, which some customers may not like 

Woeber’s  Supreme Honey Mustard

Check Price on Amazon

Fat-free Per Serving Honey Mustard To Boost Your Dressings & Dips

Woeber’s is a trusted, family-owned brand offering a high-quality, 100% natural honey mustard to suit all kinds of culinary dishes. It is also 100% kosher and all the ingredients are easily recognisable, so you know you’re not feeding your family any nasties. 

Customers who love their mustard to be sweet will really like that Woeber’s easy-squeeze supreme honey mustard is minimal in heat.

It still has mustard flavor, but sweetness is the leading taste, which makes it perfect for hot dogs, crackers, ham glazes and thick cut cheese sandwiches. 

Why we like it:

  • 100% natural & kosher
  • Low in heat
  • Versatile, sweet flavor
  • Easy-squeeze container 

What we don’t like:

  • Might not be hot enough for some tastes

Sweet Baby Ray’s Mustard Dipping Sauce 

Check Price on Amazon

Ready-To-Use Delicious Sweet & Tangy Dipping Sauce 

Sweet Baby Ray’s mustard dipping sauce is the original that started the popularity of this incredible condiment.

It has been around a long time, because it is considered by many to be the perfect combination of sweet honey and hot, tangy mustard.

If you want a classic honey mustard dip, you equip yourself with Sweet Baby Ray’s. 

Customers who really value a balance of the two key flavors in this type of condiment will love the taste of this product.

The hot, earthy mustard is delicious and tasty, and is perfectly matched with gorgeous sweet honey which makes the sauce sticky and absolutely stunning with meats and salads.

It really is the classic ‘go to’ honey mustard for lovers of tradition. 

Why we like it:

  • The perfect balance of honey and mustard
  • Versatile 
  • Easy to work with consistency 
  • Warm in flavor, but not hot 

What we don’t like:

  • Ingredients do include some colorings 
  • More ingredients overall than some more natural products 

Kens Steak House Mustard Dressing 

Check Price on Amazon

Creamy Honey Mustard From Salad Dressing Experts Ken’s

Family Business Ken’s started in the basement of a restaurant in Massachusetts and grew as the high-quality salad dressings they made became so popular.

Their gluten-free honey mustard is amongst the most popular condiments they offer, with its gorgeous sweet and tangy flavor all packed into a handy easy-squeeze bottle. 

Customers will love how versatile the product is. It can be used as it is as a crunchy crudettes dip, sandwich spread, loaded fries and wings dressing, and even for a yummy breakfast dish with a kick.

It can also be added to sauces, used as a marinade and coat roasted meat joints for a stunning family meal. It is packed full of delicious Dijon, honey, white wine and spices to form the perfect honey mustard for a huge range of culinary treats. 

Why we like it:

  • Easy-squeeze bottle
  • Made with real Dijon mustard and honey
  • Creamy, balanced flavor 
  • Versatile 

What we don’t like:

  • Customers who prefer minimal natural ingredients may not like this product
  • May not be favored if you like a spicy honey mustard

Nances Mustard Honey Dip

Check Price on Amazon

Thick & Creamy Honey Mustard Dip For A Yummy Zing

Nances signature mustard dressing has a new look, with a touch of honey added, it’s transformed into the perfect sweet and tangy dip. You can use it in sandwiches, meat dishes, sauces, marinades and as an easy dip for veggies and wings – the possibilities are endless. 

Customers will love this gorgeous thick dip made with spicy ground mustard flour and plenty of rich honey and brown sugar, for the perfect mix of spicy and sweet.

There’s nothing special about the sauce, no fancy ingredients, or gourmet recipe, it’s just good old fashioned honey mustard that works with just about anything. 

Why we like it:

  • Creamy & thick
  • Versatile

What we don’t like it:

  • Basic recipe may not be favored by customers who want gourmet or artisan 

Follow Your Heart Honey Mustard Dressing

Check Price on Amazon

Now Vegans Can Enjoy Honey Mustard Dressings Too! 

Vegans rejoice, the time has finally come for you to enjoy the incredible taste of honey mustard, without the actual use of the sweet bee nectar usually seen in this condiment.

Trendy vegan brand Follow Your Heart have pulled off the perfect creamy, tangy, sweet honey mustard sauce whilst keeping it honey, dairy, egg and nasties free. 

Vegans and people with allergies will love the FYH dressing which has a long list of natural ingredients, all based on boosting the brands famous veganaisse with spices, vegan honey alternative and other tasty extras.

Just like its real honey comparables, the sauce is absolutely delicious and can be used in salads, sandwiches, faux meat or real meat dishes – any dish you’d use non-vegan versions in! It’s so realistic, the chances are your family won’t notice the difference. 

Why we like it:

  • Suitable for vegans
  • Great for people with certain allergies
  • Versatile
  • No nasties

What we don’t like:

  • Thinner than some honey mustard sauces
  • Could be considered a higher budget product 

How To Choose The Best Honey Mustard 

If you’d love some extra tips to get the very best honey mustard in your shopping card, consider the following before making a purchase of this delicious condiment:

Balance of Ingredients

A good balance of ingredients means you get the best mixture of mustard and honey.

These kinds of products tend to be the most traditional, and you’ll get them from classic brands known for offering the best classic mustard honey on the market.

If you just want a no-fuss, delicious mustard honey, stick to the well-known brands. 

Heat

Some people love a very hot honey mustard with a delicious kick that brings something extra to a dish.

To make sure your honey mustard is as hot as you like it, consider a product that has added horseradish. Horseradish alongside mustard is a double strand of heat that will satisfy lovers of super spicy condiments. 

Extra Ingredients

If you are looking for a gourmet honey mustard then you might want to look for some interesting extra ingredients.

Artisan condiment makers know they need to be creative to add something a little different to their offerings. Ale, for example, can be added for an extra earthy, hoppy flavor that takes the honey mustard to a whole new level. 

Container

The container a condiment comes in is a small but important detail. If you want a quick barbecue condiment you can put on hotdogs, fries or steak, a squeezy bottle is the best option.

If you tend to use honey mustard in the kitchen as a base for dressings or in sandwiches, a glass jar you can spoon out of might be OK.

Of course, you can use any container in any scenario, but for ultimate convenience, dispensing without a spoon can be preferable for some. 

Budget

If you want a more budget-friendly honey mustard, choose more traditional mixes from well known brands.

If you don’t mind spending a bit more, Artisan honey mustard will cost more but will offer a few interesting flavor extras. 

Health 

With many products it is usually a good rule of thumb to say that the fewer ingredients listed, the healthier it is. However, with mustard, that isn’t always the case. Some healthier mustards have a long list of ingredients, but all of those ingredients could well be generally healthy. 

To get the healthiest mustard, try checking if you can recognise the ingredients. If they are free from colorings and E numbers, the chances are it’s a pretty good product. If you’re in doubt, do a bit of research to become more label savvy with all your purchases. 

Summary

Honey mustard is a classic tangy, sweet condiment that goes with nearly everything.

By following our tips above you can get the best product for your kitchen creations, so you can start levelling up lip-smacking meals for the family in no time. 

Get 28 Day Mediterranean Plan (100+ Recipes)

X